On Vibetheft: The Consequences of AI Abuse and a Call for Structural Changes

The rise of AI has brought on rapid transitions that have led to the proliferation of intellectual dishonesty and laziness. AI has significantly lowered the cost of entry to the creation of works of virtually any form, and encourages vibetheft, a word defined at the end of this essay, as a shortcut for human labor. People who did not spend the years of experience, training, education, failures, and recoveries, who did not experience the pain of loss and failure, the difficulty and eustress leading to the neurological changes that create the conditions needed for excellence, exploit the ease of vibecopying to vibesteal the derived outcome from the years of grinding or the gift of talent of the original creator, and cheat their way into success through a derivative work, masking their lack of skill or talent using AI as a crutch to fill the void.

Ease of unethical copying requires structural changes

In the past it was possible for an individual to read through a codebase and steal the work by rewriting it, but this was almost never done because the scale of work it would take to do this was extraordinary. The effort put into manually deriving a copy of someone else’s work was so rare and difficult, one might even look the other way for someone with that level of dedication to create a different but derivative work. By the end, the individual would likely have the skills needed to make a completely different work, so the copy was not lost in its benefits to the broader public or the individual; and if done well, it would have already taken considerable skill.

Today, that requirement has vanished completely. AI allows a person to gain nothing, learn nothing, and contribute nothing, yet profit off a derivative work that provides no value. The first problem with this is that the individual contributed nothing, but the more egregious problem with this is that one individual can vibecopy and vibesteal huge volumes of works in a short time, learning and contributing little to nothing. This then stacks, because the quantity of opportunists who lack the time, skill, and effort to build and derive their own ideas is multiplying exponentially, causing a surge in additional resources needed to maintain the ecosystems which creators depend on.

This causes a severe drain in the quality of output to the broader ecosystems, the volume of organic adoption of honestly developed products, and the resources needed to maintain the ecosystems such as app stores, forums, magazines, journals, and every other existing platform for artists, developers, writers, and intellectuals to distribute their lifetime of skills and talent that help improve our world.

By harming the distribution, adoption, and retention mechanism for real creators, the ultimate outcome of vibetheft and AI abuse is the diminishing of quality content and ultimately the degradation of the human experience as a whole. If we fail to correct this problem using fundamental structural changes with regards to law, copyright, and even redefining what open source means in the AI era, it will result in the destruction of the fabric of beauty and joy in our world and force regression of creative and intellectual consumption to a previous era, resulting in stagnation and the loss of a generation or more of human capacity.

Not a condemnation of the use of AI as a tool

In the dawn of the Industrial Revolution, between 1811 and 1816 the Luddites famously destroyed machines and actively opposed the newly cheap labor which due to machine automation resulted in cheap and inferior copies much like today’s vibetrash. This revolution changed life as we know it. But jobs did not disappear forever; they just changed. There was undeniably a time of adaptation which took decades, and the world was no longer the same.

Our current era mirrors the earlier era, but instead of machines for physical production, it is machines for intellectual production. And instead of the users of the machines being restricted to the wealthy able to build factories, everyone in the world has access to tools that can copy someone else’s intellectual work within a few minutes. Understanding the problems and implications early will help us create structural changes to mitigate this flow before it destroys the fabric of society and relegates us to regression and apathy.


Definitions

There are many forms of AI abuse, and the most prolific and egregious violation of the social contract is vibetheft. Other damaging behaviors enabled and encouraged by AI include vibecoding, vibechurning, and vibecopying. Vibetrash is what often results from these behaviors.

Vibetheft means that someone uses AI to vibecode or vibechurn a clone or vibecopy someone else’s software, music, designs, artwork, or other creative or intellectual work, to steal credit by disguising its origin or source with AI-generated changes and spun rewrites and redesigns in small or large sections, and passing it off as original, usurping the original creator through “work” which consists primarily of unskilled or thoughtless AI prompts, or is tactically churned with the deceptive intention to seize undeserved benefits, causing the original creator to lose recognition for their idea and work, with or without attribution. This includes the loss of donations, links, stars, recognition, news, publicity, credit, and other benefits for creating free and open source software or unique and useful works, which damages the foundation of the open source ecosystem and artistic and intellectual communities.

Vibecode means that someone without skill or intellectual thought or merit uses AI or AI-assisted tools to derive software and related works that would be otherwise impossible for the user and significantly above their skill level and capabilities, to the point that even when reading or seeing the final product, it would be impossible for them to understand it to the level of detail that someone who had the capability to write it with their own hands would be able to understand the same code. Vibecoding can also include people with adequate skill who lazily fail to use their own skill to guide or review the code, and as a result carelessly churn out vibetrash. The former is a matter of competence, while the latter is a matter of laziness, but the result is the same: poorly developed software.

Vibechurn extends this definition to include creative and intellectual works, including but not limited to artwork, songs, media, videos, articles, scientific papers, and anything else creative or intellectual in any field that can be produced in digital or even physical form, such as 3D printed objects, robotics, and the derivative productions of these machines, such as a robotic arm that produces humanlike handwriting with a physical pen or other writing instrument, or a robot which builds a structure autonomously. This even extends into fields such as philosophy, religion, and physics. Nothing is exempt.

Vibecopy means the copying of digital works or physical objects, including every medium, acquired through scraping, reading text or code, synthesizing radio waves, robotic “visuals”, or xrays, and any other means of converting any medium to a format detectable by AI in order to allow it to reproduce a direct or derivative copy, starting with the source, regardless of the number of changes made, up to and including a 100% different product, such as software scraped and rewritten from scratch based on the original designs, or a unique manufactured object scanned and the information acquired used to derive another 3D printed object autonomously by the AI with minimal skilled human intervention.

Vibetrash is the result of vibecoding, vibechurning, or thoughtless vibecopying. Vibecopying can be used recklessly or maliciously even by a skilled individual resulting in a product which may not be vibetrash, while still being vibetheft.

Note: This essay was written by a human, not AI.

License

On Vibetheft © by Alaric Anderson

On Vibetheft is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Leave a Reply

Welcome my friend, Helper Cat says you need to register for that! :)
Register